Kaley Cuoco has found herself at the center of a heated debate following her emotional revelation that she re-homed her beloved pitbull, Shirley, due to conflicts with her fiancé Tom Pelphrey’s German Shepherd, Blue. While Cuoco explained that the decision was made out of concern for the well-being of both dogs, many critics have accused her of prioritizing her relationship over her long-time pet, sparking discussions on loyalty in pet ownership.

Cuoco, who had raised Shirley since she was just six weeks old, shared that she made the painful choice to re-home the dog after repeated aggressive fights between Shirley and Blue. Despite her heartfelt explanation, critics have pointed out that Shirley had been a part of her life for nearly 14 years, and they believe the dog deserved to remain in the family no matter the challenges.

“You’re choosing a man over your pet. One day he’ll be out of your life and you’ll regret it,” one critic wrote.

Another commenter raised the stakes by asking, “If your boyfriend brought his kid into your home, would you give away his kid or yours if they didn’t get along? There’s no way I would give up my dog for any bf. Poor Shirley was just a disposable animal to her!”

Others echoed similar sentiments, questioning why Cuoco didn’t try harder to resolve the issue through training or behavioral programs for both dogs. “Why didn’t the boyfriend give up his dog?” one user asked. “Why couldn’t both dogs be trained to get along?”

While Cuoco’s choice has sparked backlash, it has also sparked a larger conversation about the responsibilities and loyalty involved in pet ownership. Many people feel that pets should be treated as family members, no matter the challenges, while others sympathize with Cuoco’s difficult decision, understanding that managing two pets with aggressive behavior can be an overwhelming situation.

Despite the criticism, Cuoco remains steadfast in her belief that she made the best decision for both Shirley and her growing family, ensuring Shirley had a peaceful environment during her final years.